Changing borrower insurance at any time, free of charge and without justification: this right has existed on paper since the Lemoine law of February 2022, but remained difficult to enforce in practice. In fall 2025, the DGCCRF (the French competition, consumer affairs, and fraud control authority) changed that by fining, for the first time, four major French banks for dragging their feet on their customers' requests.
Four Banks Fined Nearly €900,000
The institutions targeted are CIC Est, BRED Banque Populaire, Caisse d'Épargne Île-de-France, and the Caisse régionale de Crédit Agricole Paris Île-de-France. The individual fines range from €80,000 to more than €323,000:
- Crédit Agricole Paris Île-de-France: €323,518
- BRED Banque Populaire: €298,000
- CIC Est: €196,000
- Caisse d'Épargne Île-de-France: €80,000
In total, these four penalties amount to nearly €900,000 in fines. Notably, the banks involved are required to publish the sanction on their own website, a measure designed to ensure it is made public to customers.
A Legal 10-Business-Day Deadline Too Often Exceeded
The complaint upheld by the DGCCRF concerns the failure to comply with the legal 10-business-day deadline imposed on banks to process a request to switch loan insurance. Before the first sanctions, inspections showed that roughly one request in two exceeded this deadline, and that a third of cases waited more than 20 days for a response, delaying by that much the savings the borrower expected on their policy.
What This Means for Borrowers
Since these sanctions, several banking institutions have revised their internal procedures: strengthening dedicated teams, digitizing the processing of substitution requests, and more strictly complying with regulatory deadlines. For a household that has taken out a home loan, the principle remains simple: the cancellation request can be sent at any time, starting the day after the loan is signed, free of charge and without penalty, provided the new policy offers guarantees equivalent to the current one. The potential savings remain the main argument: over the life of a loan, the price difference between the bank's insurance and an alternative offer can amount to several thousand euros, an issue we follow closely in our Advice section as well as in our Economy analyses.
For borrowers facing a delay beyond this deadline, the process remains the same: follow up with the institution in writing, keep a record of the date the request was sent, and report any prolonged blockage to the DGCCRF or the relevant banking ombudsman.
Frequently Asked Questions
Since when can you cancel your borrower insurance at any time?
This right has existed since the Lemoine law, which took effect in February 2022, and applies starting the day after the loan offer is signed.
Which banks were fined by the DGCCRF?
Four institutions were fined in fall 2025: CIC Est, BRED Banque Populaire, Caisse d'Épargne Île-de-France, and the Caisse régionale de Crédit Agricole Paris Île-de-France, for a total of nearly €900,000 in fines.
What is the legal deadline for processing a request to change borrower insurance?
The bank has 10 business days to respond to a request to substitute loan insurance, or risk a sanction from the DGCCRF.
Sources
- Magnolia.fr – What's New in Borrower Insurance for 2026
- L'Argus de l'Assurance – A Landmark First Sanction from the Regulator
- Assurly – Historic Sanctions: Why the DGCCRF Is Fining Banks More Often
Cyber Insurance: Why AI Is Driving Up Business Premiums
Insurers now rank artificial intelligence among their top risks to watch, just behind traditional cyber threats. According to several industry studies published this month, this risk has jumped from 10th to 2nd place in the ranking of industry executives' concerns…
Cancellation, Compensation, Remote Sign-Up: Insurance Reform in France
Three regulatory texts are profoundly changing the rules of the game for insurance in France, for individuals and small businesses alike. Between compensation deadlines now set by law, easier cancellation for small and medium-sized businesses, and better-secured online sign-up, the…
Auto, Home, Health Insurance: Why Rates Are About to Climb Again
After a year already marked by rate revisions, insurers in France are preparing another increase in auto, home, and health insurance rates for 2027. According to actuarial firms Facts & Figures and Addactis, cited by several financial media outlets on…
Common Insurance Mistakes That Could Cost You Thousands
Meta description: Avoid Common Insurance Mistakes That Could Cost You Thousands in 2025. Learn how to fix coverage gaps, compare quotes, understand exclusions, and protect your finances. Insurance should prevent financial shocks, not create them. Yet many households pay too…
This article was written with the help of artificial intelligence. Editorial policy
Table des Matières




