spot_img
4.8 C
London
HomeCryptocurrencyDAC8: Council of State Rejects Bull Bitcoin's Emergency Appeal

DAC8: Council of State Rejects Bull Bitcoin’s Emergency Appeal

The legal tug-of-war over the automatic taxation of cryptocurrencies has just reached a first milestone. On September 14, 2026, the Council of State (France's highest administrative court) rejected the emergency suspension request filed by the platforms Bull Bitcoin and Paymium against the implementing decree for the European DAC8 directive, which organizes the automatic collection and transmission of crypto transaction data to tax authorities. The ruling doesn't close the case, but it does confirm, for now, that the text applies. Check out our cryptocurrency news section to follow this story as it develops.



What the DAC8 Decree Provides


Since January 1, 2026, the DAC8 directive and the OECD's international CARF standard have required crypto-asset service providers (CASPs) to collect transaction data on their European Union resident clients every year. Seventy-five jurisdictions have signed on to this framework, including the EU, the United States, the United Kingdom, and Singapore. The first automatic exchange between tax authorities, covering 2026 data, is scheduled for September 30, 2027. For more on the concrete changes this text brings for crypto-asset holders, our article on what the DAC8 directive changes breaks down the new reporting obligations.



The Arguments Rejected by the Council of State


Before France's top administrative court, Bull Bitcoin and Paymium argued that centralizing the personal and financial data of cryptocurrency users created concrete risks: data leaks, ransomware attacks, and even threats to the physical safety of identified wallet holders. They also contended that the framework could undermine liquidity in crypto markets.


In its ruling, the Council of State found that the urgency requirement wasn't sufficiently established to justify an immediate suspension of the decree. The judges concluded that the alleged privacy violation didn't, at this stage, outweigh the public interest in combating tax fraud and evasion.



A Legal Battle That Continues


The rejection of the emergency motion doesn't end the challenge. Bull Bitcoin confirmed that its appeal on the merits, which seeks to fully strike down the French decree transposing DAC8, remains pending before the Council of State. The company plans to make arguments there about fundamental freedoms and the text's compliance with the European framework for personal data protection.


This litigation unfolds against an already dense regulatory backdrop for the sector: the transition period for the European MiCA regulation ended on July 1, 2026, and more than 170 providers had already obtained their single European license by early 2026. Our article on the regulatory tightening between Brussels and Washington also covers this broader trend affecting the entire sector—also worth following in our Economy section.



Key Takeaways



  • DAC8 doesn't create any new reporting obligation for individuals: it's the crypto platform that transmits the data, not the user.

  • Form 3916-bis, used to declare crypto accounts held abroad, nonetheless remains mandatory and can now be cross-checked.

  • A discrepancy between the data transmitted by platforms and an income tax return can trigger a tax audit, with the risk of adjustments going back up to ten years.

  • Bull Bitcoin's appeal on the merits is still to be decided: the decree could still be amended or struck down.



Beyond the tax question alone, this case is also a reminder that the security of crypto-assets remains a central concern for their holders, including after death: our guide on passing on cryptocurrencies when someone dies covers another lesser-known angle of this estate planning issue.



Frequently Asked Questions


Does DAC8 require me to report my cryptocurrencies myself?


No. Platforms are responsible for collecting and transmitting the data. However, you must still file Form 3916-bis for your crypto accounts held abroad, just as you were required to before DAC8.


Has the DAC8 decree been permanently upheld in France?


No. Only the emergency suspension request was rejected, on September 14, 2026. The appeal on the merits, brought by Bull Bitcoin, is still being reviewed by the Council of State.


When will the first data be exchanged between countries?


The first automatic exchange between European tax authorities is scheduled for September 30, 2027, covering data collected during 2026.



Sources


Crypto: Brussels and Washington Tighten Regulation This Fall

This fall marks a turning point for the oversight of cryptocurrencies on both sides of the Atlantic. In Europe, the European Commission has opened a targeted consultation on the revision of the MiCA (Markets in Crypto-Assets) regulation, while in the…

Best Cryptocurrency Wallets for Security and Ease of Use

Best Cryptocurrency Wallets for Security and Ease of Use (2025) Crypto ownership keeps rising in the U.S., and so does the need for simple, secure wallets. The best cryptocurrency wallets for security and ease of use combine strong protection, smooth…

The Future of Cryptocurrency: Predictions and Trends for 2025

The cryptocurrency landscape stands at a pivotal crossroads, with digital assets having demonstrated unprecedented resilience and institutional acceptance throughout the past year. Bitcoin's remarkable journey toward mainstream adoption, coupled with regulatory clarity emerging from major economies, has set the stage…

How to Make Passive Income with Cryptocurrency

The cryptocurrency landscape has evolved dramatically, transforming from a speculative trading arena into a sophisticated ecosystem where digital assets can generate consistent returns. Gone are the days when crypto investors had to rely solely on buying low and selling high.…

This article was written with the help of artificial intelligence. Editorial policy

Les derniers articles

En découvrir plus

Editorial policy and use of artificial intelligence